Search
Close this search box.

Partner

SRIGLEY: Manufacturer Influence Puts Lasting Stain on Playoff Format

Photo: Tyson Gifford, TobyChristie.com

share it
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit

There’s no avoiding the obvious; the conclusion of Sunday’s NASCAR Cup Series event at Martinsville Speedway was pretty messy.

Following a high-intensity points battle between William Byron and Christopher Bell in the closing laps of the race, the final spot in the Championship 4 came down to a judgment call from NASCAR.

A safety violation for Bell, which stemmed from riding the wall on the final lap of the race, demoted the Joe Gibbs Racing driver from 18th to 22nd, knocking him below the cutline, in favor of Byron.

On the surface, that last-lap wall ride by Christopher Bell appeared to be the deciding factor — and as far as what NASCAR looked at in the 27-minute deliberation, it was.

After a thorough examination of in-car cameras and radio communications, it appears there may have been games played by some non-playoff drivers, which benefitted those in the fight.

In the closing laps of the XFINITY 500, William Byron was fading quickly, being passed by Ryan Blaney, Austin Cindric, and Denny Hamlin over the last 50 laps, dropping him to sixth and a single point above the cutline.

For the final 15 laps of the event, Byron managed to hold his position in sixth, with Chevrolet drivers Austin Dillon and Ross Chastain planted directly behind him, and “unable” to make the pass.

The result was an enormous huddle of cars bunched directly behind the No. 24 Liberty University Chevrolet, spanning from sixth — where Byron finished — back to his Hendrick Motorsports teammate Alex Bowman, in 13th.

Radio communications between Austin Dillon, crew chief Justin Alexander, and spotter Brandon Benesch — who was suspended at Richmond following his radio communications on the final lap — aren’t completely innocent either.

The communications also incriminate Ross Chastain, crew chief Phil Surgen, and spotter Brandon McReynolds, when Alexander [crew chief of the No. 3] asks if the No. 1 team knows of “the plan”. However, nothing suspicious can be heard on the radio of the Trackhouse Racing driver.

On the other side of things (which benefitted Christopher Bell), Bubba Wallace, a Toyota-backed driver, dramatically slowed in the final five laps of Sunday’s event, dropping from just behind the race leader into the clutches of Bell on the final lap.

Radio communications between Bubba Wallace, crew chief Bootie Barker, and spotter Freddie Kraft don’t suggest anything suspicious going on. With three laps remaining, Wallace says “I think I’ve got a tire going down” and for the remainder of the event, the No. 23 is bobbling in the corner and losing considerable amounts of pace.

Elton Sawyer, NASCAR’s Senior Vice President of Competition, said in a post-race press conference that the sanctioning body will investigate these potential race manipulation issues during the week, with any penalties being announced in the weekly penalty report.

Though, the fact of the matter is…

Manufacturer Influence Puts Lasting Stain on Playoff System

Don’t bite the hand that feeds you.

It’s an age-old saying that still rings true in the modern-day, and one that perfectly describes the current landscape of the manufacturer and team relationship.

Chevrolet, Ford, and Toyota (the three active manufacturers in the NASCAR Cup Series) currently have their allegiances and their ‘top dogs’. It’s no different than it’s always been, and that’s not going to change.

These relationships, even moreso in recent years, are crucial as NASCAR’s premier division continues to become more competitive with every passing season. But, the fact of the matter is, that the automakers hold all of the leverage.

Most of the data and information received by the teams comes directly from the manufacturer, but it’s also controlled by them, meaning that with the snap of a finger, the flow of crucial information can get dialed up, or even cut off.

That metaphorical shut-off valve has been used more frequently in recent years, especially following announcements that a particular organization, crew chief, or driver will be moving on from a manufacturer at season’s end — i.e. Travis Peterson and Michael McDowell, LEGACY MOTOR CLUB.

There’s been an increased level of talk about manufacturer allegiance in recent seasons, especially on the superspeedways. It’s ranged anywhere from pre-race competition meetings to blatant radio communications telling drivers not to push somebody from another manufacturer to the race-lead, or a victory.

Sunday’s XFINITY 500 at Martinsville Speedway is the third time since the penultimate event of the regular season at Daytona that there has been some well-documented manufacturer influence.

Parker Retzlaff was part of an enormous controversy at Daytona after he pushed a Ford Mustang (Harrison Burton) to victory while driving a Chevrolet. Later, in the Playoffs, a stink was made about Kyle Larson not giving Brad Keselowski an adequate enough push to win the race, so that the Chevrolets of Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. and William Byron could get ahead.

It’s become pretty clear that the fear of being reprimanded by a manufacturer is weighing on the minds of competitors — whether it be drivers, crew chiefs, spotters, or team members in general — and it’s totally changing the outcome of races.

“Teams are going to do, and OEMs are going to do, everything that they can. That’s how important it is to race for a championship,” said Jeff Gordon, Vice Chairman of Hendrick Motorsports. “They’re going to do everything within the rules, and as far as we know everything within the rules, and we know that if we’re not doing it, our competitors are going to be doing it.”

The conclusion of Sunday’s event at Martinsville Speedway only muddied the water further, in an iteration of the NASCAR Cup Series Playoffs that have delivered their fair share of controversy.

After the smattering of an amazing short-track event at Martinsville, many within the industry and a vocal portion of the fanbase, believe that the NASCAR Cup Series Playoffs format should be the so-called sacrificial lamb.

That includes 2012 NASCAR Cup Series champion Brad Keselowski, now a co-owner of RFK Racing (formerly Roush Fenway Racing), who following Sunday’s event posted on social media a strong message that “this should be the last straw on the camel’s back for the playoffs”.

It’s a system that has faced an incredible amount of scrutiny and disdain in the decade that it has been utilized in the NASCAR Cup Series, and with every additional controversy added to the rap sheet – like Sunday at Martinsville — the legitimacy of the format, which is often paraded for its excitement, keeps diminishing further and further.

One Response

  1. Agreed totally! I don’t thing a car owned should field more than two cars. The manufacturers should have NO say so about what happens on the track! Their communications should be cut off during qualifying and the race! I also don’t think ther should be charters either. Show up and if you qualify your in like the old days! And cool it with all the road courses. ???? Just my opinions. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Post

Erik Jones and wife Holly Jones celebrate the birth of first child son David Wayne Jones
Erik and Holly Jones Welcome First Son David Wayne Jones
Scott Osteen joins Joey Gase Motorsports as co-owner, team to be renamed Joey Gase Motorsports with Scott Osteen in 2025 NASCAR Xfinity Series
Scott Osteen Joins Joey Gase Motorsports as Co-Owner in 2025
Nitro Motorsports to compete in the 2025 ARCA Menards Series and forms technical alliance with Venturini Motorsports and Toyota Racing Development
Nitro Motorsports Joins ARCA in Technical Alliance with Venturini
23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports submitting second preliminary injunction motion in antitrust lawsuit against NASCAR
With New Evidence, 23XI/Front Row Filing Second Preliminary Injunction in NASCAR Antitrust Lawsuit
Toni Breidinger full-time NASCAR Craftsman Truck Series in 2025 with TRICON Garage
Toni Breidinger Going Full-Time NASCAR Truck Racing with TRICON in 2025
Spire Motorsports hires Matt McCall and Dax Gerrigner to competition department ahead of 2025 NASCAR Cup season
Spire Motorsports Hires Matt McCall, Dax Gerringer to Further Strengthen Competition Department

Join Our Newsletter

Ready to have NASCAR news hand-delivered to your email daily?

Related Article